Ok, the pros first. The shirt itself is what you expect from Minus33, great quality, warm, and appears to be a great shirt for cool days or a mid layer for when it get really cold. Stitching looks very good and robust, appears to be good for either tucked or untucked. The main con of this shirt is the design. It's built like a square sack with holes or for someone who has an enormous belly and fat arms. I am 6'3" and weight about 260lbs, but have an athletic build. I bought the XXL, which is my normal size with Minus33 shirts and vests, and they fit very well because of the athletic cut design. This shirt fit me in the shoulders very nice, but the rest of the shirt was incredibly big on me and loose (which is saying something, trust me...lol). A little loose is good, but this was quite billowy, and if I lept off a roof I think it might have doubled as a parachute! I did speak with Minus33 and their customer service was fantastic as always. They explained it is a new product and they are taking feedback, and offered to return it or exchange for a size down. Here is the final word on it though...I was afraid to go down a size because the shoulders fit great on the XXL, and I thought the XL would likely be too tight there. I told them I was keeping it, and paid out of pocket to have alterations to it to fit me correctly. That says a lot, at least to me. All in all I still give the shirt itself a 4/5 just because once it fit right it was really good. I wish the inside was made of a bit more softer merino (if that's possible?), but my only real chief complaint was the design. If they made it more of an athletic cut, it would be great.
Thank you for taking the time to give us your detailed feedback and review on your Minus33 White Mountain Woolen Sportsman Shirt! We are pleased to hear that you are satisfied with the overall quality of the garment and warmth that it provides. We apologize that the fit of the Sportsman was not exactly what you were looking for and that it was big on you in certain areas. We have noticed that this item does run large and we did make an adjustment to the listing, suggesting this for our future customers. It's great to hear that you reached out to our customer service team and that they were able to provide you the info you needed and offer you a solution. Thank you again for your detailed and honest feedback. It is greatly appreciated and will help us improve in the future.